Unlike other major markets in the U.S., the Twin Cities metro area has struggled to bounce back from the pandemic, negative safety perceptions, and the addition of new hotels. However, positive marketing campaigns, publicity from national sporting events, a strong convention outlook, and the potential for hosting the World Expo in 2027 should support a rebound for this lodging market.
Current Market Conditions
Coming out of past recessions, the diverse employment base has benefited the Minneapolis-St. Paul market. Major employers within the medical technology, consumer goods, healthcare, higher-education, financial, and consumer goods industries and sectors have historically generated a sufficient level of hotel demand. The natural beauty of the area attracts outdoor enthusiasts, its central U.S. location makes it a convenient destination for conventions, and the Mall of America draws visitors from around the world.
Unfortunately, in 2021 and early 2022, leisure demand was the only segment to show a strong recovery, with less corporate traffic in Downtown Minneapolis and St. Paul and a lull in convention events. However, group bookings picked up in late 2022 and remain strong for the next several years, as reported by the Minneapolis Convention Center. Additionally, many large sporting events, concerts, and festivals scheduled in 2023 are expected to generate additional demand in the metro area. Furthermore, an announcement will be made this summer regarding the host city for the World Expo 2027, with Bloomington as one of five finalists.
New Supply
- The luxury Four Seasons opened in Downtown Minneapolis in June 2022, along with six other hotels, including the Hotel Indigo (former Crowne Plaza), for a total of 875 new rooms.
- The luxury West Hotel is anticipated for the North Loop in the fall of 2023.
- While no new hotels opened in Downtown St. Paul in 2022, a 120-room Courtyard by Marriott is scheduled to open in 2023 adjacent to the Xcel Energy Center.
Additional hotel projects have been announced around the metro area; however, the volume of new hotel development is nowhere near the level realized between 2014 and 2018, and we do not expect significant supply growth to return without a substantial change in market conditions, lower construction costs, and more favorable financing.
Minneapolis-St. Paul MSA vs. Top 25 U.S. Markets
Largely due to seasonality, this MSA has always performed below the top 25 U.S. markets in RevPAR. However, in 2020 and 2021, the discount to the national RevPAR widened due to a significant loss in occupancy. The Twin Cities struggled more than other urban markets with the return of corporate and group demand in 2021 and early 2022 due to public perception regarding lack of safety in the metro area. Fortunately, leisure travel made up for some of the lost demand, resulting in a rebound to pre-pandemic ADR levels in 2022. We expect some normalization in the near term as the top 25 markets stabilize and Minneapolis-St. Paul continues to rebound.
Minneapolis-St. Paul MSA RevPAR in Comparison to Top 25 Markets’ RevPAR
Source: STR Global, STR Monthly Hotel Review
The slow return to office trend is a concern, as corporate demand remains below pre-pandemic levels, particularly in the urban cores. According to the Minneapolis Downtown Council’s 2022 annual report, nearly 64% of downtown employees are returning to work in some capacity each week, which is up more than 56% from the prior years. The impact of fewer corporate travelers is most evident in day-of-week occupancy statistics, with Thursday through Saturday registering significantly higher occupancy levels than other days of the week.
With more corporations enforcing in-office requirements, we anticipate corporate demand will continue to slowly rebound, albeit remaining below prior levels. However, the influx of strong leisure demand since the onset of the pandemic is expected to fill in softer days of the week, helping to round out some of the lost corporate demand.
Given the absorption of new supply, a favorable convention outlook, the popularity of the area for sporting events, and the quantity and diversity of major employers in the Minneapolis-St. Paul metro area, as well as the limited amount of new supply in the immediate pipeline, we expect occupancy to return to the mid-60s within the next two years. Our forecasts are illustrated below.
Historical and Forecasted Metrics for the Minneapolis-St. Paul MSA
Source: STR (Historical) and HVS (Forecast)
Hotel Transactions
As the hotel performance indices remain somewhat depressed, it is an opportunistic time for buyers to enter the Minneapolis-St. Paul market. Some recent transactions have been at a discount to prior sale prices:
- The Marriott Southwest sold in December 2022 for approximately $74,000 per room, a 28% discount to the 2014 price.
- The Sheraton Bloomington sold in July 2022 for $53,000 per room, a 22% discount to the 2013 price.
However, Monarch Alternative Capital purchased the Hotel Ivy for $226,000 per key in March 2022, which was a 53% premium over the 2013 sale price. This premium was reflective of a renovated luxury property.
Most recently, the Hilton Minneapolis was transferred to its creditors in March 2023 via foreclosure auction.
Conclusion
The long-term outlook for the Minneapolis-St. Paul hotel market is optimistic due to its diverse economy and central U.S. location. Aspects that bode well for the market going forward include the booking pace at the Minneapolis Convention Center, the popularity of the Mall of America and outdoor recreation, the strong medical-related employment base, the numerous higher-education institutions, and the number of Fortune 500 companies.
For more information, contact Tanya Pierson, MAI, of the HVS Minneapolis office.
About Tanya Pierson
Tanya Pierson, MAI, Senior Managing Director of HVS and based in the Minneapolis office, has conducted market studies, feasibility analyses, and appraisals for over 2,000 hotels and resorts in nearly every U.S. state, as well as Canada and the Caribbean. A featured speaker and panelist at major hotel conferences, she has also lectured at the University of Denver on topical issues in the U.S. lodging market. Tanya graduated from the University of Denver with a degree in Hotel, Restaurant, and Tourism Management. She is a designated member of the Appraisal Institute (MAI). Contact Tanya at (303) 588-6558 or tpierson@hvs.com.